MARSHFIELD, Wisconsin — A dairy farmer who installed a milk price tracker in the farm office said every cow now has a pay grade, although none has accepted the compensation package.
Harold Voss mounted a large whiteboard beside the bulk-tank chart and divided it into Class I, Class II, Class III and Class IV. His wife, Denise, asked which class paid for feed, electricity and the new pulsator.
“That would be the class where we keep milking,” Harold said.
Denise searched the board for that class. Harold told her it was an elective.
The cows were assigned according to temperament. Mildred, who always enters the parlor first, became Class I because she considered herself fluid leadership. Two Jerseys were placed in Class III after staring intensely at a cheese sandwich. The dry cow was classified as “policy development” and moved to the corner where no measurable production could interfere with her recommendations.
The Milk Price Tracker Requires Four Colored Markers
Harold had been using the Milk Price and Policy Tracker to review milk classes, component pricing, milk-check deductions and federal-order resources. The directory warns that it is educational and not a live price feed. Harold appreciated that honesty. His milk check was also educational and rarely seemed connected to anything happening live on the farm.
The USDA Agricultural Marketing Service explains Federal Milk Marketing Orders as systems that establish classified pricing and minimum prices for milk purchased by regulated handlers. Harold explained this to his banker using four colored markers, three arrows and a drawing of a cow whose udder had become a flowchart.
The banker studied it for several minutes.
“Which number is yours?” he asked.
Harold circled all of them and wrote “eventually” underneath.
Denise pointed out that the federal system distinguishes milk by use, while their grocery store distinguishes it by whether the carton has a picture of grass. Harold added a fifth column labeled “Milk With Encouraging Scenery” and priced it high enough to cover the ink.
Butterfat Receives a Corner Office
The farm’s component report arrived in the afternoon. Butterfat was promoted immediately and given a corner office in the refrigerator. Protein received a modest raise. Other solids were told they were essential to the organization but should not expect their names on the door.
Harold calculated hundredweights on a yellow legal pad while Denise reconciled hauling, promotion assessments and cooperative deductions. The gross milk value occupied the top line and looked prosperous. The deductions followed beneath it in orderly formation, like relatives arriving because somebody mentioned an inheritance.
By the bottom of the page, the milk check had become a postcard from money.
Harold said the tracker helped him identify the relationship between cheese, butter, powder and the price paid for milk. Denise said she had identified the relationship: cheese had a retail price, butter had a retail price, powder had a retail price, and Harold had a meeting.
The Cows Request Transparent Compensation
At evening milking, Harold taped the four-class chart to the parlor wall. Mildred examined it, kicked the takeoff unit loose and returned to collective bargaining.
The Jerseys refused to acknowledge their cheese assignment without tasting samples. One Holstein moved herself from Class II to Class IV by standing next to the butterfat column and looking confident. Harold allowed the transfer because confidence is the only credential still accepted without paperwork.
Denise entered the month’s estimated revenue into the farm budget. Harold asked whether the new figure was encouraging.
“It is a figure,” she said. “Let’s not burden it with emotion.”
Before leaving the office, Harold updated the board. He used the current class-price report, checked the component values and wrote the milk-check estimate at the bottom. Then he added one more line for feed costs.
The feed line erased the motivational portion of the presentation.
Harold said the milk price tracker had finally made the system understandable. Four classes of milk, several component prices, regional differentials, deductions and a cow named Mildred now agreed on one point: the check would be easier to explain if it arrived with a pie chart and a small apology.
Farm.FM Disclaimer
This report is entirely a human collaboration between two sentient beings — the world’s oldest tenured professor and a philosophy major turned dairy farmer. Neither was assigned a milk class. Both were deducted for hauling.
Last Updated on November 17, 2026 by Alan Nafzger
A milk price tracker that assigns every cow a pay grade has a sense of humor, and butterfat should not be the only one with a corner office. The useful part is still the check after deductions. I read dairy market news and milk price reports alongside those parlor rankings, because a pay grade is not a market, and the deductions have a way of outranking the cows.