ROCHESTER, Minnesota — A dairy producer has asked for hazard pay after setting a milk statement beside a convenience-store receipt and realizing one of the liquids in the comparison came from a cooler that never once needed to call a veterinarian. She has asked the cooler for its business plan. It has so far refused to comment.
“I saw the water had a picture of a mountain,” said dairy farmer Ellen Mott. “I can show you a mountain behind our barn, but I doubt they’d let me put it on the label.”
Farm Milk Prices Meet the Convenience-Store Cooler
Mott’s evidence consisted of a milk check measured by weight and a chilled water bottle sold by the unit. Her son pointed out that she was comparing what a farm receives for bulk milk with what a shopper pays for a packaged product. Mott agreed and asked how many individually packaged cows she would have to sell before the bank took the difference seriously.
The USDA overview of Federal Milk Marketing Orders describes a system that classifies milk by use and sets minimum prices under applicable orders. A farm’s statement can reflect components and other adjustments. Store shelf prices include a separate chain of processing, packaging and distribution costs. Mott says she understands all of that and would still appreciate an invitation to whatever meeting assigned a premium to a twist-off cap.
At the farm’s informal tasting, three neighbors agreed they could detect water in the water. One wanted to know why there were two kinds. The youngest person at the table said one came from the tap. It had performed well until she told them.
“My cows give us milk whether or not the label has a waterfall,” said dairy farmer Paul Ferris. “If a waterfall ever figures out how to make butterfat, I’ll consider it real competition.”
Hazard Pay Has a Budget Line, Temporarily
Mott penciled in hazard pay for the person who does the early milking, the person who checks the bulk tank and the person who explains the milk statement. Her husband objected that all three were her. She said he had just identified the project’s strongest economy of scale.
For a more useful comparison at the farm level, she keeps track of revenue and costs per hundredweight using figures from the same period. Her family also records which bills recur and which can be traced directly to a nephew saying he could handle it himself.
Dairy farmer Anita Burrows said she shared the complaint with the man stocking the supermarket cooler. He sympathized until she asked him to stand in her parlor at four in the morning and explain why water did not need a second shift.
“I bought one anyway,” Burrows said. “I was thirsty from explaining why it cost too much.”
Mott has since placed a bottle of tap water in her own refrigerator with a handwritten label describing a distant spring. Her husband says it tastes like the tap. She told him that is why the spring is distant.
Farm.FM satire disclaimer. The bottle’s marketing department declined to wake up for morning milking.
