Thanksgiving pie prices have prompted the Wilkes family to divide dessert into surveyed parcels, reserve the mineral rights and prohibit Uncle Roy from acquiring adjoining slices through what he calls natural expansion.
Grandmother Edna unveiled the arrangement beside a pumpkin pie and a ruler. Each guest received a clearly defined interest in the surface filling. Rights below the crust remain with the estate.
“I baked it,” she said. “I’m keeping the underlying assets.”
Thanksgiving Pie Prices Reach the Closing Table
This week’s reporting on weather pressure and holiday pie ingredients describes growers and bakers dealing with uneven supplies, damaged crops and costly adjustments. Those problems can affect particular ingredients even when a broader holiday dinner basket moves in another direction.
Farmer Ben Wilkes emphasized that cheaper grain does not automatically produce a cheaper pie at every counter. Flour, fruit, labor, transportation, energy and somebody washing the mixing bowl all occupy separate lines in the bill.
Roy said this was too much economics for something that ought to come with coffee.
Edna replied that he had just consumed enough whipped cream to qualify as a processing facility.
An Apple Receives a Formal Appraisal
The family’s apple pie arrived under unusually close supervision. Ben carried it with both hands while his daughter cleared a route through the kitchen. Their dog was asked to maintain a respectful distance from the collateral.
Edna had bought suitable fruit early and used her freezer to manage supply. Roy called this speculation. Ben said it was remarkable how storing apples becomes financial engineering when the alternative is listening to Roy complain about crackers.
The family discussed the old mock-apple-pie approach, in which crackers can stand in for scarce fruit. Roy declared that a cracker had no right to impersonate an apple. His niece asked whether he applied the same standard to the artificial bacon bits he brought to every gathering.
Ben said farmers understand that recipes begin long before the kitchen. An orchard cannot replace a lost season by authorizing overtime on the trees. A pumpkin does not become ready sooner because the supermarket has already put out its Thanksgiving display.
Dessert Develops an Inheritance Problem
The first dispute concerned a sliver left between two cuts. Roy claimed it was an unleased tract. Edna classified it as a surveying error and ate it to prevent litigation.
The second concerned leftovers. Three relatives expressed interest in future possession while still occupying their current slices. Ben proposed a cooling-off period equal to however long it took to wash the plates.
For ordinary households, Edna recommends planning portions, comparing actual ingredient costs and choosing a dessert that fits the budget. Seasonal substitutions can be perfectly respectable. Nobody needs a second mortgage to establish that Thanksgiving happened.
The family approved those principles unanimously, then asked whether she had made another pie.
She had. It was hidden in the pantry, beyond the jurisdiction of the dining-room conversation.
Roy immediately offered to negotiate access.
Edna explained that the second pie was subject to a conservation easement: it would remain intact until somebody conserved enough energy to help with the dishes.
For the first time all afternoon, the market cleared.
Satirical disclaimer: No mineral rights beneath the pie changed hands. Our ceremonial human collaboration pairs two sentient beings—the world’s oldest tenured professor and a philosophy major turned dairy farmer—who remain available to argue about the underlying evidence.
